A probation service fit for the future | Nacro

A probation service fit for the future

Published:

This is the fifth in a series of briefings that examine the steps that can be taken to support people in contact with the criminal justice system to create better futures. This report shares the views and experiences of people who have been supervised by probation.

The purpose of the report is not to develop a list of recommendations but to ensure that the experiences of those who have been under probation supervision are shared and heard and taken into account.

The Probation Service plays a critical role in supporting and supervising people in contact with the justice system. It’s a service that has been under pressure for many years, and as the changes introduced by the Sentencing Act take effect more people will be supervised by probation in the community. This will mean that probation will play an even bigger role in the justice system, supporting people to turn their lives around as well as keeping our communities safe.

74 people were interviewed for the report, either individually or in focus groups, and members of Nacro’s Justice ExChange helped shape the content of this report.

Summary

We’ve highlighted the following emerging themes from our interviews:

Fulfilling the dual role of probation through effective rehabilitation: The most effective way to protect the public is to support effective rehabilitation, enabling people leaving custody to build a stable life and contribute to society. If the focus on public protection and the management of risk takes precedence over rehabilitation, or becomes the sole focus, rehabilitation can be undermined, and lasting change can then be limited.

Recruitment and training of probation staff: The feedback from people who have been supervised by the Probation Service and the qualities they believe to be key in probation officers should directly inform recruitment and training. These include honesty; listening and people skills; empathy and a caring non judgmental attitude.

Lower risk doesn’t equal lower need: As probation supervision changes to prioritise those who present the highest risk, those with a wide range of needs, such as mental health, substance misuse and housing must not be overlooked. Those who represent less immediate or severe risk to the public are often people caught in the revolving door of offending, or at risk of their offending becoming prolific if they aren’t able to access support.

Recall: The huge increase in the use of recall has clearly impacted the relationships people have with their probation officers. The framework to support decisions to recall needs to support effective decision-making and be fair and proportionate, balancing public protection with the impact on the rehabilitation of the individual.

Pre-sentence reports: The capacity of probation to prepare high-quality presentence reports in conjunction with each individual is essential to ensure that sentencing decisions are well-informed and consider how to best to support rehabilitation and reducing reoffending.

Probation in prisons: Effective transitions from prison to community are only possible if supported by smooth handovers between prison and community probation officers ensuring sharing of information and release plans with licence conditions that are informed by previous engagement and supportive of growth.

Employing people with lived experience in both probation and the voluntary sector: The insight and experiences of people with lived experience are invaluable to creating a diverse and knowledgeable workforce that can best support people on probation. To make this a reality there must be a greater focus on mentoring roles, overcoming current barriers of vetting, stigma and lack of relevant work experience.

Read the report